(My thought process was created with the aid of my wonderful sister Ms. Molly Lewis, and she deserves a lot of credit for what is about to be written. Just so everyone knows.)
Both Austen and Gaskell follow similar if not identical storylines. Girl meets boy, girl dislikes boy for character flaws, boy likes girl for her personality (helped along by her being remarkably handsome), girl rejects boy, girl realizes boy is awesome; girl and boy share a wonderful and beautiful moment in the final pages and make me wish I lived hundreds of years ago. Also make me consider trying to bring back that style of necktie. They look so dashing. The same right? Not so fast!
The difference lies in the characters perception of themselves and what they deserve. The two scenes that best represent what I mean are the same in both books. The initial proposals are both met with vehement rejection, but the man’s attitude in each is different. While Darcy is assured in his own mind of success, Thornton hardly allows himself to hope. Success for Darcy would simply be a realization of his own self-worth, while for Thornton it is something only imaginable, beyond belief. Darcy feels that he deserves Elizabeth. Thornton knows that Margaret is too good for him. By the end of each novel the two people are together. While Austen gives a sense of real happiness between her two lovers, Gaskell does more. And her version of love is what I want in my own life.
Thornton knows that he doesn’t deserve Margaret. Margaret knows that she doesn’t deserve Thornton. Darcy and Elizabeth may live happy together until their deaths and if so that’s wonderful. But Mr. and Mrs. Thornton will live every day of their lives together feeling like the luckiest people in the world. If you can’t wake up in the morning and look at your husband or wife and feel that kind of emotion, then I think that you are missing out. And that’s why I’m still single ;)
I kid. I don’t think that I have too inflated an idea of my own self-worth; I think that I need someone who challenges me. And yes Molly, I read the ending of North and South four times. It was beautiful.